Key Takeaways

• Easy Pay Direct requires an approved merchant account before any Shopify connection happens.
• Approval is typically 1 to 4 business days; a complete, accurate application is the biggest factor in speed.
• Online rates generally run 2.4% to 2.7% plus a per-transaction fee, with a roughly $99 setup fee and $25 to $36 monthly.
• Disputifier has a confirmed, documented NMI connection; Chargeflow’s compatibility with this specific setup isn’t confirmed.
• Easy Pay Direct’s own REST API and webhooks make a custom tracking-sync tool genuinely buildable, not just theoretical.

---

If you’ve read a generic “add a payment gateway to Shopify” guide and tried to apply the same steps to Easy Pay Direct, you’ve probably hit a wall. That’s expected. Easy Pay Direct isn’t a native Shopify payment option you activate with a click; it’s a dedicated merchant account with real underwriting behind it, and the Shopify connection happens after approval, not instead of it.

Step 1: Apply for Your Easy Pay Direct Merchant Account

Of course, the first step is to apply for your Easy Pay Direct merchant account.

To start, you’ll enter:

• Your first and last name
• Company email address
• Phone number
• Legal business name
• Expected annual processing amount
• Website or social media URL

Easy Pay Direct uses real human underwriting rather than an automated score, matched to a bank that already works with your specific industry. Approval typically takes one to four business days on a clean file, and longer for complex cases.

What Makes an Application “Clean?”

Approval speed comes down to how complete and consistent your application is, not luck. A few things that keep a review moving:

• Business formation documents that match your actual legal business name exactly
• Bank account details that match your business name, not a personal account
• Clear, accurate product or pricing information consistent with what’s actually on your Shopify store
• Processing history, if you have one, including honest disclosure of any prior account terminations

Applications that slow down tend to have mismatched information between the application and the actual live store, incomplete documentation, or a business category that needs additional underwriting review (see below).

What “High-Risk” Actually Covers

Easy Pay Direct underwrites more than 47 verticals across several risk categories, and dropshipping and print-on-demand specifically fall into this broader high-risk umbrella, not because the business model itself is inherently problematic.

But, because of the pattern mainstream processors associate it with:

• Longer shipping windows from overseas suppliers
• Less direct control over product quality (i.e. dropshipping or print-on-demand)
• A correspondingly higher dispute rate

If that describes your store, that’s exactly the kind of business this setup is built for, not a red flag against you.

What Can You Do if You’re Declined?

A decline isn’t necessarily final. Easy Pay Direct’s underwriting team can often explain what specifically drove the decision, and reapplying with corrected documentation or clarified business details is a real path forward in many cases. If your business genuinely doesn’t fit after that, PayPal runs separate underwriting and, in some instances, may accept what a dedicated high-risk account wouldn’t, depending on the reason for decline.

Step 2: Connect Your Account to Shopify

Once approved, Easy Pay Direct connects to Shopify through the NMI (Network Merchants Inc.) gateway framework, the payment technology platform Easy Pay Direct’s gateway runs on behind the scenes, rather than as a standalone native Shopify app.

What actually determines which connection path you get isn’t something you control upfront; it depends on your specific account configuration, which Easy Pay Direct’s integration team assigns during setup. 

Since which path you get isn’t something you decide yourself, the most direct route is simply asking your integration team during onboarding rather than attempting both.

One thing worth knowing regardless of path: Shopify only allows one third-party card provider active at a time, so connecting Easy Pay Direct replaces whichever provider was previously active, not run alongside it.

Step 3: Test a Transaction

When setting up a new payment path, always run a real test transaction and confirm that it appears correctly in both your Shopify order history and Easy Pay Direct Gateway reporting. First, you need to enable test mode in Shopify. 

Then, the test transaction process depends on which connection path you’re using, since the test cards and test mode settings differ by gateway framework.

For the Authorize.net Emulator Path (most common)

Easy Pay Direct’s own documentation directs you to use Authorize.net test cards when connected through Shopify’s Authorize.net provider slot.

To start, enable test mode:

1. In your Shopify admin, go to Settings → Payments
2. In the Authorize.net section, click Edit
3. Check “Use test mode” and enter sandbox credentials
4. Click Save

Then, run the test order:

1. Visit your store as a customer would, add a product, and proceed to checkout
2. Use Authorize.net test card numbers (the standard Visa test number is 4111111111111111 with any future expiry date and any 3-digit CVV)
3. Complete the checkout

After that, verify:

• Check your Shopify admin → Orders to confirm the order appears
• Log into your Easy Pay Direct Gateway reporting to confirm the transaction shows there

Important caveat: Authorize.net’s test servers aren’t fully compatible with Shopify’s checkout, so test mode through the Authorize.net emulator can be unreliable. Authorize.net transactions submitted in test mode also won’t appear in your Authorize.net reports — they’re simulated and not stored.

For the NMI Gateway (Direct Marketplace Apps Path)

Since Easy Pay Direct runs on the NMI gateway framework, NMI’s own test cards apply if you’re connected through the direct Marketplace Apps path.

• Use expiry date 10/29 and any CVV. To trigger a declined transaction, set the amount to less than $1.00.
• To enable NMI test mode: Toggle your NMI merchant account into Test Mode from the NMI control panel.

While in test mode, all valid credit cards will be “approved” without actual charges or processing.

The Alternative: Real Transaction + Immediate Refund

If test mode isn’t cooperating (which is common with the Authorize.net emulator setup) Shopify recommends the fallback approach → place a real order with a genuine credit card, then immediately cancel and refund it.

Here’s how:

1. Make sure your Easy Pay Direct connection is active (not in test mode)
2. Place a real order from your store using your own credit card
3. Log into your Easy Pay Direct Gateway reporting to confirm the funds were processed
4. Cancel and refund the order immediately
5. Note that any third-party transaction fees charged by Easy Pay Direct are typically not refunded

Avoid Common Mistakes with Easy Pay Direct Payment Testing

A common mistake is to use Shopify’s own test cards (like 4242424242424242); don’t do this because these are for Shopify Payments and Shopify’s Test payment gateway only. So, they won’t work with a third-party gateway like Easy Pay Direct. The test cards you need must match the underlying gateway framework (NMI or Authorize.net emulator), not Shopify’s internal test system.

Some people also forget to disable test mode.

After you’re done testing, disable test mode on both sides:

1. Toggle your NMI/Easy Pay Direct gateway back to Live Mode.
2. Uncheck “Use test mode” in Shopify’s Authorize.net settings.

Customers can’t place live orders while test mode is active.

How Much Will You Pay Running Easy Pay Direct on a Shopify Store?

This is worth knowing before you apply, not after. Easy Pay Direct’s online rates typically run 2.4% to 2.7% plus a per-transaction fee, generally lower than flat-rate processors at real volume, though pricing is quoted per merchant and vertical rather than a single universal number. 

On top of the transaction rate, expect:

• A roughly $99 one-time setup fee
• A monthly account fee typically in the $25 to $36 range

Easy pay direct also comes with extra setup The extra setup step is the tradeoff for what you get on the other side: a dedicated merchant account underwritten by an actual person, placed with a bank that already works with your specific industry. That tends to mean more account stability than an algorithmic processor that can flag or freeze an account with limited human review behind the decision.

Compare that against what you’re currently paying (or would pay on Shopify Payments or a flat-rate competitor) before deciding the extra setup time is worth it.

To see how the platform breaks down next to Stripe, PayPal, and Shopify Payments directly, check out our full payment processor comparison.

How to Handle Refunds & Recurring Billing

Easy Pay Direct’s gateway supports tokenized card vaulting and recurring billing natively, confirmed directly through its own REST API, which includes dedicated endpoints for charges, subscriptions, and refunds. If your store sells subscriptions or recurring products, this is handled at the gateway level, not something you need a separate tool for.

For refunds specifically: Easy Pay Direct’s API supports issuing them directly, though whether a refund initiated through Shopify’s own order admin automatically syncs back to Easy Pay Direct’s records depends on your specific connection path (Marketplace App versus Authorize.net emulator). Confirm this directly with your integration team during setup so you know your actual day-to-day refund workflow before you need it for a real order.

Which Chargebacks & Dispute Tools Work With Shopify & Easy Pay Direct?

For chargeback & dispute management, most sellers need two tools: 

1. Dispute management automation
2. Tracking number syncing

Both Disputifier and Chargeflow offer automated dispute management with confirmed, documented connection to NMI. If you’re running Easy Pay Direct through the NMI framework, either dispute-management tool can help.

For tracking number syncing, Easy Pay Direct publishes its own REST API (OpenAPI 3.1 specification, with official TypeScript and Python SDKs) covering charges, customers, subscriptions, refunds, and disputes, along with webhooks for real-time transaction and dispute events. That means a custom tracking-sync tool is a concretely scoped, buildable project, not a vague possibility.

At a high level, here’s what that would actually involve:

• A small server or serverless function (something like a Vercel or AWS Lambda function) that listens for Shopify’s orders/fulfilled webhook
• When a fulfillment event fires, the function pulls the tracking number and order details from Shopify’s payload
• It then calls Easy Pay Direct’s API, using their published SDK, to attach that tracking information to the corresponding transaction record

So what does this actually mean for you? For a developer comfortable with webhooks and REST APIs, this is realistically a few days of work, not a major project, largely because Easy Pay Direct’s own SDKs handle most of the integration complexity already. If you don’t have a developer on hand, this is worth scoping out as a small freelance project rather than something to build yourself from scratch.

For the devs out there, you might also like: 53 App Marketplaces to Find Your Next SaaS Idea

Switching to or Away From Easy Pay Direct

If you’re switching from another processor, existing recurring billing or saved customer cards tied to your previous processor don’t automatically transfer. Customers with saved payment methods will generally need to re-enter their details once Easy Pay Direct is active, so it’s worth communicating that transition to active subscribers directly rather than letting them discover a failed renewal.

If you want to switch away from Easy Pay Direct later, reconnecting a different provider in Shopify’s payment settings is a standard settings change, not a technical barrier. Contract terms, including any early termination considerations, are worth confirming directly with Easy Pay Direct during your initial application, since those terms aren’t something a general guide can responsibly state on your behalf.

Final Thoughts

Easy Pay Direct’s setup takes longer than clicking “activate” on PayPal or Stripe, and that’s by design. The underwriting step that adds a few days upfront is the same thing that gives you more account stability once you’re actually processing, which matters most for exactly the businesses, dropshipping and print-on-demand included, that standard algorithmic processors tend to flag or decline.

To ideate, plan, and launch an online business from scratch, claim your free Aurajinn launch dashboard today. 

Frequently Asked Questions About Easy Pay Direct & Shopify